AI & Machine Learning

I Built an AI Feature. It Wasn't a Product. Here's What Changed.

A

Adil Sher

Author

Nov 18, 2026
5 min read
3 views
I Built an AI Feature. It Wasn't a Product. Here's What Changed.

Last year, I shipped what I thought was going to be a game-changer. A React component that integrated with GPT to generate personalized email sequences. It worked beautifully in the demo. I showed it to our product team, got approval, and pushed it to production feeling genuinely proud.

Three weeks later, we realized it was barely being used. Not because the AI wasn't smart or the technical implementation was flawed, but because I'd built a feature, not a product. Users didn't understand what the AI was doing or why they should trust it. The workflow didn't fit into how they actually worked. There was no feedback loop, no learning mechanism, nothing that made them want to return. Reading through PraxisAI's journey, I realized I'd made almost every mistake they'd solved for.

That experience taught me something that's stuck with me: the gap between "AI works" and "AI solves a real problem for real people" is often wider than the entire journey from zero to that working prototype.

The Prototype Trap

Here's the thing nobody tells you when you're first learning about LLMs: getting an AI model to do something is maybe 20% of the actual work. The other 80% is everything around it.

I can prove this with my own experience. When I integrated my first LLM API call, I spent maybe two days. The model was responsive, the prompts were solid, and technically it was sound. But then came the questions that broke my brain:

What happens when the model hallucinates? How do users know that happened? Should we show them the raw output or sanitize it? How do we let them correct it? What if they run the same input twice and get different outputs, is that a bug or just how these systems work? Should we charge per token or per use?

A prototype doesn't have to answer any of those questions. A product does. That's the actual boundary.

Building With the User's Problem, Not the Model

I started thinking about PraxisAI's approach differently after I'd already shipped my broken feature. They didn't start with "how do we build a cool AI thing?" They started with "counselling students need safe, repeatable practice environments, and that's expensive to provide with human supervisors."

The AI became the means, not the end. That's a crucial distinction I missed.

When I redesigned that email component, I flipped my thinking entirely. Instead of asking "what can the AI do?", I asked "what's the actual workflow a user goes through when creating emails?" The AI still generated the sequences, but now it lived inside a broader experience: users could select tone, review suggestions, provide feedback, iterate. The AI output became useful because the product context gave it meaning.

The difference in adoption was immediate and measurable.

What Actually Changed for Me

Reading through their seven-stage development lifecycle, I recognized that my original approach had skipped steps 1-3 entirely. I'd jumped straight to "build a prototype" without really understanding the user problem or validating that AI was even the right solution.

Here's what I do differently now:

I spend time with actual users first. Not hypothetical users. Real people doing the work. I watch them struggle. I let them fail. I understand their constraints, time, budget, technical literacy, trust levels.

I explicitly ask: could this be solved without AI? Sometimes the answer is yes, and that saves months of work. Sometimes it's no, and then I know AI is genuinely solving a problem, not just adding complexity.

I prototype the workflow before I perfect the model. A rough prototype with a good UX beats a perfect model with a confusing interface. I can iterate the model later. The workflow is what gets people using it.

I build for reliability over cleverness. Users need to understand what's happening and why. I add structure, guardrails, transparency. Sometimes this means the AI feels less magical but substantially more trustworthy.

The Real Question

Where I still struggle: How do you know when you've built the right product, not just a working prototype? The article talks about deployment and measurement, but that's vague. You ship, you measure, you iterate. But how do you distinguish between "needs more iteration" and "this was the wrong direction"?

I think the answer is in defining success metrics that actually matter to users, not just technical metrics. Not "API response time" but "did this save you time?" Not "accuracy rate" but "did you trust the output enough to act on it?"

That's the gap I'm still closing on my own work.

What's one AI feature you've built that felt clever but didn't stick with users? I'd genuinely like to know what I'm missing.


Source: This post was inspired by "From AI Prototype to Real Product: What We Learned Building PraxisAI" by Dev.to. Read the original article

Share this article

Written by Adil Sher

Full stack developer building high-traffic platforms, AI services, and custom web applications. Explore my portfolio, learn about my background, or get in touch.

Related Articles

Stop Chasing LLM Hype: Why I'm Building with Small Models Now
AI & Machine Learning Nov 17

Stop Chasing LLM Hype: Why I'm Building with Small Models Now

A year ago, I was that developer. You know the type, throwing everything at GPT-4, spinning up expensive API calls for tasks that didn't need them, and justifying it all with "but it's the most capable model." Then I got a bill that made me pause.

Why I'm Finally Taking AI Agent Tooling Seriously (And You Should Too)
AI & Machine Learning Nov 15

Why I'm Finally Taking AI Agent Tooling Seriously (And You Should Too)

Last month, I spent three hours debugging a Python script that was supposed to pipe images into Claude for analysis. The script worked locally, failed in my CI pipeline, and broke again when I switched machines. Halfway through, I realized I was building the wrong thing entirely-...